What's the "link level header" in "minus its link level header" for the -x flag?

Guy Harris gharris at sonic.net
Thu Apr 30 15:06:35 EDT 2020


(Opening this up to the full tcpdump-workers list, to get more user input.)

On Apr 30, 2020, at 11:40 AM, Francois-Xavier Le Bail <devel.fx.lebail at orange.fr> wrote:

> The tcpdump manual states:
> 
>       -x     When parsing and printing, in addition to printing  the  headers
>              of  each  packet,  print the data of each packet (minus its link
>              level header) in hex.  The  smaller  of  the  entire  packet  or
>              snaplen  bytes  will  be  printed.  Note that this is the entire
>              link-layer packet, so for link layers that pad (e.g.  Ethernet),
>              the  padding  bytes  will  also be printed when the higher layer
>              packet is shorter than the required padding.
> 
> In "minus its link level header" (singular, thus one header), link level header should be understood
> as the DLT link level header ?
> 
> E.g. for "IP over Fibre Channel printer" (print-ipfc.c), the LL header length is IPFC_HDRLEN (16) or
> caplen if the packet is truncated ?
> 
> I ask the question because sometimes some other LL length are taken in account (LLC, etc.).
> I think it is confusing to mix in the "minus its link level header" the DLT LL and other upper layer
> link layers.
> 
> We should just take in account the pseudo-header length in some cases e.g. DLT_NETANALYZER,
> DLT_NETANALYZER_TRANSPARENT, etc., added to Ethernet header length.

My *guess* is that the most *useful* interpretation of "link level header" is "whatever, in an IP packet, would come before the IP header".

So that'd include, for example, the LLC header.

It would also, of course, take into account any metadata pseudo-headers, such as the NetAlyzer headers the radiotap header for 802.11.


More information about the tcpdump-workers mailing list